The World of a Geek

A student, casual gamer, and anime lover thoughts

Apple iPhone vs. Windows Mobile-powered phones

What’s better, an Apple iPhone or a Windows Mobile powered PDA? Well before we could jump to conclusion, we should check them via these qualifications:

-Combatibility to different computer platforms

-Multimedia

-Trendiness and stylishness

-Price

-Connectivity

-Software Flexibility (e.g. Installing software/games)

-Network Compatibility

-Data storage

Point one – compatibility to different computer platforms

The Apple iPhone could be accessed by any computer platform provided that you have necessary software to control/manage the device. It is detected as a flash drive on any platform. On Windows, iTunes controls the device, of course there are alternative software available on the internet that offers more/less functionalities. On Mac OS X, iTunes also control/manage the device. Maybe there are some alternatives also. However, on Linux, you must get other software such as gtkpod (maybe) to control/manange the device.

Windows Mobile-powered phones connectivity to computer platforms may depend on the manufacturer. I think Windows Mobile can be only accessed by Windows OS.

WINNER: Apple iPhone. It’s inter-compatibility may be one of it’s good features

Point two – Multimedia

The Apple iPhone has a built-in iPod which supports the popular media formats. The Music could be synched from your computer to the device. Photos and Videos are also synched. Same goes for your contacts. It has a loudspeaker also. It’s 2 Megapixel camera is enough for you to capture photos and videos with ease.

A Windows Mobile-powered phones supports some media formats and it is also a good video player. Depending on the brand, these devices may come or not with a camera and/or loudspeaker. Some brands that offer Windows Mobile-powered phones are offering a better camera quality than Apple iPhone 2MP camera.

WINNER: Tie. The phones support the popular media formats and it’s good cameras could make dispose your digicam.

Point three – Trendiness and Stylishness

Apple iPhone maybe the trendiest smartphone in the market today. It’s looks may even make some people drool over it (like me :D ). It is very stylish for the average style-concious people. I read somewhere that a man liked it’s looks and would not like to use it, for it not to get a scratch! :)

Windows Mobile-powered phones may or may not be stylish. The HTC Touch and LG’s newest smartphone(I forgot the model) can be stylish as the iPhone.

WINNER: Tie. Both the phones can be stylish as the other.

Point four – Price

The Apple iPhone is around 20K here in the Philippines or US$399. I still do not know what is the price of the iPhone in Europe since the price is not yet announced.

Depending on the brand a Windows Mobile-powered phone could be cheaper or more expensive than the iPhone

WINNER: Windows Mobile-powered phones. Although some are more expensive, some brands offfer their devices at a cheaper price than the iPhone

Point five – Connectivity

The Apple iPhone only have Bluetooth and WiFi (802.11b/g). Also, the lack Bluetooth device pairing maybe a deal braker. It is not compatible with enterprise-level secure networks and services (e.g. Blackberry, Windows Exchange Server). It is connected to a computer via USB.

Depending on the brand a Windows Mobile-powered phones may offer a wide range of connectivity options. Some have WiFi, Bluetooth (with pairing), and Infrared. It can be compatible with Blackberry provided that you have a software extention or software in your device. Connected to the computer via USB.

WINNER: Windows Mobile-powered phones. Their wide range of connectivity options is an edge over the iPhone

Point six – software flexibility

The Apple iPhone is a closed-platform (i.e. Software installation is not allowed) device. Applications are only available via the Safari Web Browser.

Software and/or games can be installed on the Windows Mobile-powered phones.

WINNER: Windows Mobile-powered phones.

Point seven – network compatibility

The Apple iPhone is only compatible on all GSM networks, provided that you unlocked it. Yes, it does not support 3G.

A Windows Mobile-powered phone could be compatible to 3G networks and does not need cracking for it to be compatible to all networks.

WINNER: Windows Mobile-powered phones.

Point eight – Data storage

The Apple iPhone has an 8 GB storage. It cannot be expanded

A Windows Mobile-powered phone’s capacity data storage may depend on the manufacturer. Generally, the data storage could be expanded on major brands.

WINNER: Tie.

OVERALL WINNER: WINDOWS MOBILE-POWERED PHONES [4-6 (iPhone-Windows Mobile)]

November 3, 2007 - Posted by thetechieotaku | Apple, Mac, Microsoft | , , , , | 7 Comments

7 Comments »

  1. May I add some points? I totally agree with your conclusion. Only some of the arguments are debatable:
    Point 1: You can connect a Windows Mobile device to a Mac using “The Missing Sync” by Mark/Space… and there are Linux-implementations, too, so that one is a tie IMHO.
    Point 4: The price in Europe will be EUR 399,- (about USD 520,-). this is a bit higher than the average WM device. What makes the iPhone lose here is the fact that the contract you have to “buy” with the device costs you minimum EUR 49,- per month (including a data flatrate and 100 minutes talk time per month)… and that is much more than any WM device has. To be fair: the price for the monthly package is okay compared to other carriers or even T-Mobile themselves. The difference is that with no other device you are forced to use such a monthly plan!
    Point 5: Apple refused to include the A2DP profile (High quality Audio) which every WM device has nowadays. Thus an iPhone user is not able to use a bluetooth stereo headphone to listen to his songs…. which is, IMHO, a shame!
    Point 7: TO be fair, this one must be a tie… most of the WM smartphones are netlocked (most of all on the T-Mobile network), so the iPhone is not especially bad.

    Comment by worldofppc | November 5, 2007 | Reply

  2. Also note that Apple has announced a software development kit for the iPhone for February and then there will be a lot of software available. Also if you hack it you already have many programs to choose from – though not as much choice as for Windows Mobile (yet)!

    Comment by ralf | November 17, 2007 | Reply

  3. Website Translation Software Designed to make websites & Blogs Multilingual.
    Reach out to an international audience, Software to make your Site/Blog Multilingual. Reach out to the other 70%
    of the World who cannot read English. A lot of people in the Americas and the world speak languages other than
    English. In such a scenario, it is best to maintain websites which offer people a choice of their preferred language
    Site Translator, designed for Website/Blog owners who need a simple, do-it-yourself solution to Website
    Language translation with only a few mouse clicks, Site Translator will translate virtually any Website designed in HTML, ASP, XML and ASP.net. It translates only the language content and leaves the source code unchanged. Unlike the word-substitution software that requires manual substitution of words or phrases, Site Translator
    Intelligently identifies and translates phrases.
    Site Translator uses automated machine translation technology. The automated translation technology is capable
    of translating entire Web sites in a matter of minutes and you do not need to know the translated language. If
    you need to improve accuracy and customize the process, Site Translator has a feature called translation
    memory, which helps you fine-tune exact language phrases.
    Download Free feature limited Trial Version!!
    With Site Translator you can: Translate between 14 language pairs – covering languages spoken by over 90% of internet users
    Extract and translate the words from your website source code
    Convert your whole site to your desired language without having headaches of writing the individual pages manually
    Get your website or Blog listed on country specific search engines
    Improve accuracy using Translation Memory by saving common phrases
    Site Translator supports 14 language pairs for translation:

    English-German English-French English-Spanish
    English-Italian English-Portuguese English-Dutch
    French-English German-English German-French
    French-German Dutch-English Portuguese-English
    Spanish-English Italian-English

    The software does all the work. Bring your Web site to the other 60% of the web world-Those that do not speak English! VISIT
    http://www.multilingual-website-software.pipbiz.com
    Site Translator is probably the best Software for web/Blog translation on Web just now.

    Happy 2008 to all my contacts and a BIG thank you Webmaster to include my copy.
    Pipbiz

    Comment by pipbiz | December 17, 2007 | Reply

  4. a very nice blog

    Happy new year

    http://www.myposts4u.blogspot.com

    Comment by danan | January 1, 2008 | Reply

  5. very interesting.
    i’m adding in RSS Reader

    Comment by music | January 9, 2008 | Reply

  6. I find that buying an Iphone is a very easy because there are no upgrades or different types. One Iphone and you get everything. You plans may vary depending on your needs. When you buy an Iphone you don’t have to get the Internet athought you should. It needed for all the bells ans whistles. The good thing is that the web fees are only 19.95 per month, this is half the cost or less than any other provider YES!!! I find this site has the best plans and phones available.

    http://www.cellplansonline.com

    Feel free to email me with any questions.

    Comment by John | February 1, 2008 | Reply

  7. i say the iPhone is a much more user-friendly fone. its more appealing to the people to bcoz its resembles an iPod. i think the iPhone should have won the stylishness part.

    Comment by OneBandila | February 22, 2008 | Reply


Leave a comment